Comment on `Reviewing the evidence for two-proton emission from the high-spin isomer in $^{94}$Ag'

Mukha, I.; Roeckl, E.; Grawe, H.; Tabor, S.L.

Comment on `Reviewing the evidence for two-proton emission from the high-spin isomer in $^{94}$ Ag'

I. Mukha
(
- Valencia U., IFIC and
- Valencia U.
)
,
E. Roeckl
(
- Darmstadt, GSI
)
,
H. Grawe
(
- Darmstadt, GSI
)
,
S.L. Tabor
(
- Florida State U.
)

Aug, 2010

2 pages

e-Print:

1008.5346 [nucl-ex]

View in:

ADS Abstract Service

pdf

reference search1 citation

Citations per year

Abstract: (arXiv)

A recent publication [D.G. Jenkins, Phys. Rev. C \textbf{80}, 054303 (2009)] claims to discredit the experimental observation of two-proton decay of the (21

^+

) high-spin isomer in

^{94}

Ag [I. Mukha \emph{et al.,} Nature (London) \textbf{439}, 298 (2006)]. Its conclusion, which would require a reestablishment of the two-proton emission, is made on the basis of unwarranted assumptions by Jenkins concerning the data analysis of the original work. We provide proof that these assumptions do not correspond to reality, and that therefore the conclusion of the paper is misleading.

Note: