MOND from a brane-world picture

Yacov (Jacob) Bekenstein contributed greatly to the development of MOND theory. His TeVeS was the bellwether to diverse relativistic-MOND formulations. However, none of the theories we have today is fully satisfactory, and, importantly, we still lack understanding of the roots of the MOND phenomenology. Groping for such understanding I describe a heuristic picture where (nonrelativistic) MOND dynamics emerge in a universe viewed as a nearly spherical brane embedded in a higher-dimensional flat space Ԑ. The brane (centered at ξ = 0) is described by ξ(Ω); ξ and Ω are the radial and angular coordinates in Ԑ. It couples to a radial potential ε(ξ) in Ԑ as εσ; σ is the brane density. The brane tension, T, balances the ε force at radius ξ = ℓ0, implying a^0≡| ε′(l0) |≈T/σl0, yielding for the velocity of small brane perturbations c2≈T/σ≈l0a^0. Local mass density ρ(Ω) ≪ σ also couples to ε through ερ. The radial ε′ ρ force induces shallow brane indentations ζ(Ω)=ξ(Ω)−l0, |ζ|≪l0, which, in turn, affect masses in a way that makes ϕ ≡ε[ ξ(Ω) ]≈ϕ0+a^0ζ play the role of gravitational potential. To get MOND dynamics, the brane Lagrangian is assumed a functional of the local brane orientation, whose normal makes an angle θ with the radial direction, |tanθ|=|∇→ζ|=|∇→ϕ|/a^0. Thus, some a0∼a^0≈c2/l0 plays the role of the MOND acceleration constant in local gravitational dynamics. Aspects of MOND that may emerge naturally as geometrical properties are: a. The special role in MOND of an acceleration, a0, that marks the transition from dynamics much above a0 (large brane slopes) to scale-invariant dynamics much below a0 (small slopes). b. The intriguing connection of a0 with cosmology. c. The Newtonian limit corresponds to local departure | ζ |≪l0; i.e., ϕ−ϕ0∼a0ζ≪a0l0∼c2 – whereas relativity enters (but not treated here) when | ζ |≪l0. The model also opens new vistas for extension, e.g., it points to possible dependence of a0 on ϕ, and to a0 losing its status and meaning altogether in the relativistic regime. It also reinforces the view that global (cosmological) and local (e.g. galactic) MOND dynamics have to be understood together as inseparable parts of the same construction. The ‘old’ cosmological-constant problem is addressed: the ‘cosmological’ effects of large brane energy density T are cancelled (balanced) by the action of the ε field. The balance is achieved at some radius ℓ0 with space attaining a nearly spherical geometry. This geometry, when interpreted within general relativity, is characterized by a ‘cosmological constant’ Λ≈l0−2. With a view to generalizing the model to space-time branes I discuss possible connections with the nearly-de-Sitter nature of our Universe.

Note:

17 pages, 1 Figure. Added a figure describing the schematics of the brane dynamics. To appear in Jacob Bekenstein Memorial Volume: The Conservative Revolutionary (World Scientific)

membrane model: tension
gravitation: potential
gravitation: local
space: embedding
effect: nonlocal
MOND
acceleration
perturbation theory
cosmological constant
higher-dimensional