Fast-rotating galaxies do not depart from the MOND mass-asymptotic-speed relation

Feb 24, 2020
4 pages
e-Print:

Citations per year

20212022202301
Abstract: (arXiv)
Ogle et al. have fallaciously argued recently that fast-rotating disc galaxies break with the predictions of MOND: the 6 fastest rotators of the 23 galaxies in their sample appear to have higher rotational speeds than is consistent with the MOND relation between the baryonic mass of a galaxy, MM, and its `rotational speed', VV. They interpret this departure as a break in the observed MVM-V relation from a logarithmic slope near the MOND-predicted 44, to a shallow slope of 0\approx 0. However, Ogle et al. use the MAXIMAL rotational speed of the galaxies, VmaxV_{max}, not the ASYMPTOTIC one, VV_\infty, which appears in the MOND prediction, V4=MGa0V_\infty^4=MGa_0. Plotting their MM vs. VmaxV_{max} pairs on an MM vs. VV_\infty plot from Lelli et al. (2016), they arrive erroneously at the above tension with MOND. The HαH_\alpha rotation curves used by Ogle et al. are far too short reaching to probe the asymptotic regime, and determine VV_\infty. However, it is well documented for fast rotators with observed, extended, HI rotation curves, that they can have VmaxV_{max} considerably larger than the MOND-relevant VV_\infty [Noordermeer and Verheijen (NV) (2007) and others]. E.g., the fastest rotator in the NV sample has Vmax490 km/sV_{max}\approx 490{\rm ~km/s}, but V250 km/sV_\infty\approx 250{\rm ~km/s}. NV also show that in a (MOND-irrelevant) MVmaxM-V_{max} plot the high-speed galaxies fall off the power-law line defined by the lower-speed ones, creating a break in the MM vs. VV relation, in just the way claimed by Ogle et al. But, when plotting the MOND-relevant MM vs. VV_\infty all galaxies fall near the same power-law relation, without a break.
Note:
  • 4 pages
  • galaxy: mass
  • rotation
  • MOND
  • rotator
  • slope
  • tension