Quantum isomorphism of graphs from association schemes

Sep 9, 2022
21 pages
e-Print:

Citations per year

0 Citations
Abstract: (arXiv)
We show that any two Hadamard graphs on the same number of vertices are quantum isomorphic. This follows from a more general recipe for showing quantum isomorphism of graphs arising from certain association schemes. The main result is built from three tools. A remarkable recent result of Mančinska and Roberson shows that graphs GG and HH are quantum isomorphic if and only if, for any planar graph FF, the number of graph homomorphisms from FF to GG is equal to the number of graph homomorphisms from FF to HH. A generalization of partition functions called "scaffolds" affords some basic reduction rules such as series-parallel reduction and can be applied to counting homomorphisms. The final tool is the classical theorem of Epifanov showing that any plane graph can be reduced to a single vertex and no edges by extended series-parallel reductions and Delta-Wye transformations. This last sort of transformation is available to us in the case of exactly triply regular association schemes. The paper includes open problems and directions for future research.
Note:
  • 21 pages
  • [1]
    cinska, D.E. Roberson, R. ˇ Sámal, S. Severini, A. Varvitsiotis
    • A. Atserias
      ,
    • L. Man
  • [2]
    Algebraic Combinatorics I
    • E. Bannai
      ,
    • T. Ito
  • [3]
    On the Einstein Podolsky Rosen paradox
    • J.S. Bell
      • Physics 1 (1964) 195-200
  • [4]
    Distance-Regular Graphs. SpringerVerlag, Berlin
    • A.E. Brouwer
      ,
    • A.M. Cohen
      ,
    • A. Neumaier
  • [5]
    An optimal lower bound on the number of variables for graph identification
    • J. Cai
      ,
    • M. Fürer
      ,
    • N. Immerman
      • Combinatorica 12 (1992) 389-410
  • [6]
    Distance-regular graphs, Electronic J. Combin
    • E.R. van Dam
      ,
    • J.H. Koolen
      ,
    • H. Tanaka
  • [7]
    An algebraic approach to the association schemes of coding theory
    • P. Delsarte
  • [8]
    Graph Theory
    • R. Diestel
  • [9]
    Algebraic Combinatorics. Chapman and Hall, New York
    • C.D. Godsil
  • [10]
    Quantum symmetries of Hadamard matrices. Preprint
    • D. Gromada
  • [11]
    Strongly regular graphs and spin models for the Kauffman polynomial
    • F. Jaeger
      • Geom.Dedicata 44 (1992) 23-52
  • [12]
    On spin models, triply regular association schemes, and duality
    • F. Jaeger
      • J.Algebr.Comb. 4 (1995) 103-144
  • [14]
    Operations with structures
    • L. Lovász
      • Acta Math. 18 (1967) 321-328
  • [15]
    cinska and D. E. Roberson. Quantum homomorphisms, J. Combin
    • L. Man
  • [16]
    cinska and D. E. Roberson. Quantum isomorphism is equivalent to equality of homomorphism counts from planar graphs, in: 61st FOCS
    • L. Man
  • [17]
    cinska, D. E. Roberson and A. Varvitsiotis
    • L. Man
  • [18]
    Commutative association schemes, Europ. J
    • W.J. Martin
      ,
    • H. Tanaka
  • [19]
    Scaffolds: A graph-theoretic tool for tensor computations related to Bose-Mesner algebras
    • W.J. Martin
      • Linear Algebra Appl. 619 (2021) 50-106
  • [20]
    Hadamard equivalence via graph isomorphism
    • B.D. McKay
      • Discrete Mathematics 27 (1979) 213-214
  • [21]
    Exponentially many Hadamard designs, Des. Codes Cryptogr. 38 , 297-308
    • E. Merchant
  • [22]
    Spin models constructed from Hadamard matrices, J. Combin
    • K. Nomura
  • [23]
    Quantum isomorphic strongly regular graphs from the E8 root system, Preprint
    • S. Schmidt
    • [24]
      A characterization of P- and Q-polynomial association schemes, J. Combin
      • P. Terwilliger
    • [25]
      Course lecture notes, Math 846 Algebraic Graph Theory, Spring term, University of Wisconsin
      • P. Terwilliger