Annealing for prediction of grand canonical crystal structures: Implementation of n-body atomic interactions

Jul 6, 2023
14 pages
Published in:
  • Phys.Rev.A 109 (2024) 3, 032416
  • Published: Mar 15, 2024
e-Print:
DOI:

Citations per year

20222023202401
Abstract: (APS)
We propose an annealing scheme usable on modern Ising machines for crystal structures prediction (CSP) by taking into account the general n-body atomic interactions and in particular three-body interactions which are necessary to simulate covalent bonds. The crystal structure is represented by discretizing a unit cell and placing binary variables which express the existence or nonexistence of an atom on every grid point. The resulting quadratic unconstrained binary optimization (QUBO) or higher-order unconstrained binary optimization (HUBO) problems implement the CSP problem and is solved using simulated and quantum annealing. Using the example of Lennard-Jones clusters we show that it is not necessary to include the target atom number in the formulation allowing for simultaneous optimization of both the particle density and the configuration and argue that this is advantageous for use on annealing machines as it reduces the total amount of interactions. We further provide a scheme that allows for reduction of higher-order interaction terms that is inspired by the underlying physics. We show for a covalently bonded monolayer MoS2 crystal that we can simultaneously optimize for the particle density as well as the crystal structure using simulated annealing. We also show that we reproduce ground states of the interatomic potential with high probability that are not represented on the initial discretization of the unit cell.
Note:
  • 14 pages, 9 figures, completely revised version with QA results and full SA analysis
  • [1]

    Crystals from first principles

    • J. Maddox
  • [2]

    Structure prediction drives materials discovery

    • A.R. Oganov
      ,
    • C.J. Pickard
      ,
    • Q. Zhu
      ,
    • R.J. Needs
  • [3]

    High-pressure phases of silane

    • C.J. Pickard
      ,
    • R.J. Needs
  • [4]

    Structure of phase III of solid hydrogen

    • C.J. Pickard
      ,
    • R.J. Needs
  • [5]

    random structure searching

    • C.J. Pickard
      ,
    • R.J. Needs
  • [6]

    Perspective: Role of structure prediction in materials discovery and design

    • R.J. Needs
      ,
    • C.J. Pickard
  • [7]

    Minimum-energy configurations of atomic clusters: New results obtained by simulated annealing

    • L. Wille
  • [8]

    Simulated annealing and the topology of the potential energy surface of Lennard-Jones clusters

    • L. Wille
  • [9]

    Search methods for inorganic materials crystal structure prediction

    • X. Yin
      ,
    • C.E. Gounaris
  • [10]

    Minima hopping: An efficient search method for the global minimum of the potential energy surface of complex molecular systems

    • S. Goedecker
  • [11]

    Crystal structure prediction using the minima hopping method

    • M. Amsler
      ,
    • S. Goedecker
  • [12]

    Evolutionary programming techniques for predicting inorganic crystal structures

    • T.S. Bush
      ,
    • C.R.A. Catlow
      ,
    • P.D. Battle
  • [13]

    Crystal structure prediction using

    • A.R. Oganov
      ,
    • C.W. Glass
  • [14]

    How evolutionary crystal structure prediction works—and why

    • A.R. Oganov
      ,
    • A.O. Lyakhov
      ,
    • M. Valle
  • [15]

    New developments in evolutionary structure prediction algorithm USPEX

    • A.O. Lyakhov
      ,
    • A.R. Oganov
      ,
    • H.T. Stokes
      ,
    • Q. Zhu
  • [16]

    Crystal structure prediction via particle-swarm optimization

    • Y. Wang
      ,
    • J. Lv
      ,
    • L. Zhu
      ,
    • Y. Ma
  • [17]

    Computer-assisted inverse design of inorganic electrides

    • Y. Zhang
      ,
    • H. Wang
      ,
    • Y. Wang
      ,
    • L. Zhang
      ,
    • Y. Ma
  • [18]

    Cryspy: A crystal structure prediction tool accelerated by machine learning

    • T. Yamashita
      ,
    • S. Kanehira
      ,
    • N. Sato
      ,
    • H. Kino
      ,
    • K. Terayama
    et al.
  • [19]

    A hybrid computational–experimental approach for automated crystal structure solution

    • B. Meredig
      ,
    • C. Wolverton
  • [20]

    X-ray diffraction data-assisted structure searches

    • P. Gao
      ,
    • Q. Tong
      ,
    • J. Lv
      ,
    • Y. Wang
      ,
    • Y. Ma
  • [21]

    Crystal structure prediction supported by incomplete experimental data

    • N. Tsujimoto
      ,
    • D. Adachi
      ,
    • R. Akashi
      ,
    • S. Todo
      ,
    • S. Tsuneyuki
  • [22]

    Search for common minima in joint optimization of multiple cost functions

    • D. Adachi
      ,
    • N. Tsujimoto
      ,
    • R. Akashi
      ,
    • S. Todo
      ,
    • S. Tsuneyuki
  • [23]

    A noise-robust data assimilation method for crystal structure determination using powder diffraction intensity

    • S. Yoshikawa
      ,
    • R. Sato
      ,
    • R. Akashi
      ,
    • S. Todo
      ,
    • S. Tsuneyuki
  • [24]

    Accelerating simulated annealing of glassy materials with data assimilation

    • Y. Zhao
      ,
    • R. Sato
      ,
    • S. Tsuneyuki
  • [25]