A review and analysis of six extended Wigner's friend arguments

Aug 30, 2023
32 pages
e-Print:

Citations per year

202220232024202517
Abstract: (arXiv)
The Wigner's friend thought experiment was intended to illustrate the difficulty one has in describing an agent as a quantum system when that agent performs a measurement. While it does pose a challenge to the orthodox interpretation of quantum theory, most modern interpretations have no trouble in resolving the difficulty. Recently, a number of extensions of Wigner's ideas have been proposed. We provide a gentle introduction to six such arguments, modifying the specifics of many of them so that they are as simple and unified as possible. In particular, we show that all of the arguments hinge on assumptions about correlations between measurement outcomes that are not accessible to any observer, even in principle. We then provide a critical analysis of each argument, focusing especially on how well one can motivate the required assumptions regarding these inaccessible correlations. Although we argue that some of these assumptions are not entirely well-motivated, all of the arguments do shed light on the nature of quantum theory, especially when concerning the description of agents and their measurements.
Note:
  • Minor changes. 32 pages, 9 figures; comments welcome!
  • [1]

    Three measurement problems

    • T. Maudlin
  • [2]

    On the quantum measurement problem

    • C. Brukner
  • [3]

    A no-go theorem for observer-independent facts

    • C. Brukner
  • [4]

    Quantum theory cannot consistently describe the use of itself

    • D. Frauchiger
      ,
    • R. Renner
  • [5]

    Not even subjective truth survives contact with quantum theory

    • L. del Rio
      ,
    • R. Renner
  • [6]

    Testing quantum theory with thought experiments

    • N. Nurgalieva
      ,
    • R. Renner
  • [7]

    Is QBism 80% complete, or 20%?

    • M. Pusey
  • [8]

    What are Copenhagenish interpretations and should they be perspectival?

    • M. Leifer
  • [9]

    Quantum theory and the limits of objectivity

    • R. Healey
  • [10]

    When Greenberger, Horne and Zeilinger meet Wigner’s Friend

    • G. Leegwater
  • [11]

    A no-go theorem for absolute observed events without inequalities or modal logic

    • N. Ormrod
      ,
    • J. Barrett
  • [11]
    if one finds in the lab that sometimes a=- and b=-, then one has experimentally ruled out the assumptions going into the argument. (The fact that Eqs. (53), (54) and (55) are not themselves experimentally falsifiable is not relevant to this point; one may view them simply as facts used in establishing the argument—facts which are motivated by quantum theory and formulated in a theory-independent way.)
    • N. Ormrod
      ,
    • J. Barrett
    • [12]

      A strong no-go theorem on the Wigner’s friend paradox

      • K.-W. Bong
    • [13]

      Implications of local friendliness violation for quantum causality

      • E.G. Cavalcanti
        ,
      • H.M. Wiseman
    • [14]

      A possibilistic no-go theorem on the wigner’s friend paradox

      • M. Haddara
        ,
      • E.G. Cavalcanti
    • [15]

      A

      • H.M. Wiseman
        ,
      • E.G. Cavalcanti
        ,
      • E.G. Rieffel
      • [15]

        Local Friendliness no-go theorem: a prospective experiment with new assumptions to suit

        • H.M. Wiseman
          ,
        • E.G. Cavalcanti
          ,
        • E.G. Rieffel
      • [16]

        Allowing Wigner’s friend to sequentially measure incompatible observables

        • E.G. Cavalcanti
          ,
        • H.M. Wiseman
      • [17]

        Quantum theory is incompatible with relativity: A new proof beyond bell’s theorem and a test of unitary quantum theories

        • S. Gao
      • [18]

        A no-go theorem for the persistent reality of Wigner’s friend’s perception

        • P. Allard
      • [19]

        How quantum mechanics can consistently describe the use of itself

        • D. Lazarovici
          ,
        • M. Hubert
      • [20]

        A general framework for consistent logical reasoning in Wigner’s friend scenarios: subjective perspectives of agents within a single quantum circuit

        • V. Vilasini
          ,
        • M.P. Woods
      • [21]

        Single-worldtheory ofthe extendedWigner’s friend experiment

        • A. Sudbery
      • [22]

        Respecting one’s fellow: Qbism’s analysis of wigner’s friend

        • J.B. DeBrota
          ,
        • C.A. Fuchs
          ,
        • R. Schack
      • [23]

        On QBism and assumption (Q)

        • B.C. Stacey