Pushing the Boundary of Quantum Advantage in Hard Combinatorial Optimization with Probabilistic Computers

Chowdhury, Shuvro; Aadit, Navid Anjum; Grimaldi, Andrea; Raimondo, Eleonora; Raut, Atharva; Lott, P. Aaron; Mentink, Johan H.; Rams, Marek M.; Ricci-Tersenghi, Federico; Chiappini, Massimo

Pushing the Boundary of Quantum Advantage in Hard Combinatorial Optimization with Probabilistic Computers

Shuvro Chowdhury
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)
,
Navid Anjum Aadit
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)
,
Andrea Grimaldi
(
- Heriot-Watt U. and
- Messina U. and
- Bari Polytechnic
)
,
Eleonora Raimondo
(
- Heriot-Watt U. and
- Messina U. and
- ING, Rome
)
,
Atharva Raut
(
- UC, Berkeley
)

Mar 13, 2025

e-Print:

2503.10302 [quant-ph]

View in:

ADS Abstract Service

pdf

reference search0 citations

Citations per year

0 Citations

Abstract: (arXiv)

Recent demonstrations on specialized benchmarks have reignited excitement for quantum computers, yet whether they can deliver an advantage for practical real-world problems remains an open question. Here, we show that probabilistic computers (p-computers) when co-designed with hardware to implement powerful Monte Carlo algorithms surpass state-of-the-art quantum annealers [\href{https://www.nature.com/articles/s41586-023-05867-2}{King et al., Nature (2023)}] in solving hard optimization problems. We focus on two key algorithms: discrete-time simulated quantum annealing (DT-SQA) and adaptive parallel tempering (APT), both applied to 3D spin glasses. For DT-SQA, we find that increasing the number of replicas improves residual energy scaling, while parallelizing fewer replicas across independent runs also achieves comparable scaling. Both strategies align with the theoretical expectations from extreme value theory. In addition, APT outperforms DT-SQA when supported by non-local isoenergetic cluster moves. Finite-size scaling analysis suggests a universal behavior that explains the superior performance of APT over both DT-SQA and quantum annealing. We show that these algorithms are readily implementable in modern hardware thanks to the mature semiconductor technology. Unlike software simulations, replicas can be monolithically housed on a single chip and a large number of spins can be updated in parallel and asynchronously, similar to a quantum annealer. We project that custom Field Programmable Gate Arrays (FPGA) or specialized chips leveraging massive parallelism can further accelerate these algorithms by orders of magnitude, while drastically improving energy efficiency. Our results challenge the notion of a practical quantum advantage in optimization and present p-computers as scalable, energy-efficient hardware for real-world optimization problems.

References(62)

Figures(24)

[1]

Simulating physics with computers

Richard P. Feynman
(
- Caltech
)

- Int.J.Theor.Phys. 21 (1982) 467-488,
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF02650179

[2]

Tatsuhiro Onodera, Martin M Stein

Logan G. Wright

[3]

Maxwell Aifer, Kaelan Donatella, Max Hunter Gordon, Samuel Duffield, Thomas Ahle, Daniel Simpson, Gavin Crooks, and Patrick J Coles. Thermodynamic linear algebra. npj Unconventional

- Computing 1 (2024) 13

[4]

Navid Anjum Aadit, Andrea Grimaldi, Mario Carpentieri, Luke Theogarajan

John M. Martinis

- Nature Electron. 5 (2022) 460-468

[5]

How to Build a Quantum Supercomputer: Scaling from Hundreds to Millions of Qubits

Masoud Mohseni
(
- Hewlett-Packard, Bristol
)
,
Artur Scherer
(
- Unlisted, CA
)
,
K. Grace Johnson
(
- Hewlett-Packard, Bristol
)
,
Oded Wertheim
(
- Tel Aviv U.
)
,
Matthew Otten
(
- Wisconsin U., Madison
)

et al.

e-Print:
- 2411.10406

[6]

Algorithms for quantum computation: discrete logarithms and factoring. In Proceedings 35th annual symposium on foundations of computer science, pages 124-134

Peter W. Shor

[7]

Frank Arute, Kunal Arya, Ryan Babbush, Dave Bacon

Joseph C. Bardin

[8]

Quantum principal component analysis

- Nature Phys. 10 (2014) 631-633,
- Nature Phys. 10 (2014) 631
•
e-Print:
- 1307.0401
•
DOI:
- 10.1038/nphys3029

[9]

Hsin-Yuan Huang, Michael Broughton, Jordan Cotler, Sitan Chen, Jerry Li, Masoud Mohseni, Hartmut Neven, Ryan Babbush, Richard Kueng, John Preskill, and Jarrod R. McClean. Quantum advantage in learning from experiments. Science, 376 (6598):1182-1186

[10]

Shuvro Chowdhury

Kerem Y. Camsari

[11]

Computational complexity and fundamental limitations to fermionic quantum Monte Carlo simulations

Matthias Troyer
(
- Zurich, ETH
)
,
Uwe-Jens Wiese
(
- Bern U.
)

- Phys.Rev.Lett. 94 (2005) 170201
•
e-Print:
- cond-mat/0408370
•
DOI:
- 10.1103/PhysRevLett.94.170201

[12]

Accelerated quantum Monte Carlo with probabilistic computers

Shuvro Chowdhury
(
- UC, Santa Barbara (main)
)
,
Kerem Y. Camsari
(
- UC, Santa Barbara (main)
)
,
Supriyo Datta
(
- Purdue U.
)

- Commun.Phys. 6 (2023) 1, 85,
- Commun.Phys. 6 (2023) 85
•
e-Print:
- 2210.17526
•
DOI:
- 10.1038/s42005-023-01202-3

[13]

Naoya Onizawa and Takahiro Hanyu. Gpu-accelerated simulated annealing based on p-bits with real-world devicevariability modeling

- Sci.Rep. 15 (2025) 6118

[14]

Block, Peter Virnau, and Tobias Preis. Multi-GPU accelerated multi-spin Monte Carlo simulations of the 2D Ising model

- Comput.Phys.Commun. 181 (2010) 1549-1556

[15]

Tobias Preis, Peter Virnau, Wolfgang Paul, and Johannes J Schneider. GPU accelerated Monte Carlo simulation of the 2D and 3D Ising model

- J.Comput.Phys. 228 (2009) 4468-4477

[16]

Kun Yang, Yi-Fan Chen, Georgios Roumpos, Chris Colby, and John Anderson. High performance Monte Carlo simulation of Ising model on TPU clusters. In Proceedings of the International Conference for High Performance Computing, Networking, Storage and Analysis, pages 1-15

[17]

Ye Fang, Sheng Feng, Ka-Ming Tam, Zhifeng Yun, Juana Moreno, Jagannathan Ramanujam, and Mark Jarrell. Parallel tempering simulation of the three-dimensional Edwards- Anderson model with compact asynchronous multispin coding on GPU

- Comput.Phys.Commun. 185 (2014) 2467-2478

[18]

Shaila Niazi, Shuvro Chowdhury, Navid Anjum Aadit, Masoud Mohseni, Yao Qin, and Kerem Y. Camsari. Training deep Boltzmann networks with sparse Ising machines

- Nature Electron. 7 (2024) 610-619

[19]

All-to-all reconfigurability with sparse and higher-order Ising machines

- Nature Commun. 15 (2024) 1, 8977,
- Nature Communications (2024)
•
e-Print:
- 2312.08748
•
DOI:
- 10.1038/s41467-024-53270-w

[20]

Navid Anjum Aadit, Masoud Mohseni, and Kerem Y Camsari. Accelerating Adaptive Parallel Tempering with FPGA-based pbits. In

[20]

Symposium on VLSI Technology and Circuits (VLSI Technology and Circuits), pages 1-2

[21]

Navid Anjum Aadit, Andrea Grimaldi, Mario Carpentieri, Luke Theogarajan, Giovanni Finocchio, and Kerem Y Camsari. Computing with invertible logic: Combinatorial optimization with probabilistic bits. In

[21]

International Electron Devices Meeting (IEDM), pages 40-3

[22]

Navid Anjum Aadit, Andrea Grimaldi, Giovanni Finocchio, and Kerem Y Camsari. Physics-inspired ising computing with ring oscillator activated p-bits. In

[22]

22nd International Conference on Nanotechnology (NANO), pages 393-396

1-25 of 62
1
2
3
25 / page