Stardust findings favor not only the planetary origin of comets but the underlying close-binary cosmogony of the Solar system as well

Feb, 2007
14 pages
Published in:
  • Icarus 197 (2008) 203-210
e-Print:

Citations per year

20072008200901
Abstract: (arXiv)
We analyze findings of the Stardust mission that brought to the Earth dust from the 81P/Wild 2 coma. Just as the data of the Deep Impact mission to 9P/Tempel 1, they are at odds with the widely accepted condensation/sublimation comet paradigm. They fit rather well to the approach assuming ejection of nuclei of short-period comets from moon-like bodies of the type of Galilean satellites in rare (six to seven events in 4.5 aeons) global explosions of their massive icy envelopes saturated by 2H2+O2, products of the electrolysis of ice. This approach offers an explanation, in particular, for the jet activity of comets, which is sustained by combustion of the 2H2+O2+organics mixture ignited and complemented by the solar radiation. Combustion accounts also for other observations, in particular, the presence in the dust of products of high-temperature (800-900 K) metamorphism. The presence of minerals forming at still higher temperatures (~1400-2000 K), just as the undoubtedly planetary origin of some long-period comets arriving from the joint planeto-cometary cloud beyond Neptune, forces one, however, to invoke the close-binary cosmogony of the Solar system, which three decades ago predicted the existence of such a cloud (in the recent decade, this prediction has been substantiated by the discovery there of many dwarf planets). It considers the Jupiter-Sun system as the limiting case of a binary star and uses it as a basis for explanation of all the known observations and for prediction of the new ones to come. It provides an explanation, in particular, for both the origin and capture by the Earth of the Moon as a high-temperature condensate and the formation of the Galilean satellites, which also contain inclusions of refractory minerals in their ices.
  • SOLAR SYSTEM FORMATION
  • TRANSNEPTUNIAN PLANETS
  • TEMPEL 1
  • WILD 2
  • 2006, Whence comets?
    • A'Hearn M.F.
      • Science 314 1708
  • and 32 colleagues, 2005, Deep Impact: Excavating Comet Tempel 1. Science
    • A'Hearn M.F.
    • 1994, Density of Comet Shoemaker-Levy 9 deduced by modeling
      • Asphaug E.
        ,
      • Benz W.
      • breakup of the parent ‘rubble pile’
          • Nature 370 120
      • 2007, A collisional family of icy
        • Brown M.E.
          ,
        • Barkume K.M.
          ,
        • Ragozzine D.
          ,
        • Schaller E.L.
        • objects in the Kuiper belt
            • Nature 446 294
        • Sekanina
          • Brownlee D.E.
            ,
          • Horz F.
            ,
          • Newburn R.L.
            ,
          • Zolensky M.
            ,
          • Duxbury T.C.
          et al.
          • Z 2004, Surface of young
            • Tsou P.
              ,
            • Hanner M.S.
              ,
            • Clark B.C.
              ,
            • Green S.F.
              ,
            • Kissel J.
            • and 182 co-authors, 2006, Comet 81P/Wild 2 under a microscope. Science 314
              • Brownlee D.
              • 2002, The existence of a planet beyond 50 AU and the orbital
                • Brunini A.
                  ,
                • Melita M.D.
                • distribution of the classical Edgeworth-Kuiper-Belt objects
                    • Icarus 160 32
                • 1973, Accumulation process in the primitive solar nebula
                  • Cameron A.G.W.
                    • Icarus 18 407
                • 2001, Making more terrestrial planets
                  • Chambers J.E.
                    • Icarus 152 205
                • 2003, Blowing in the wind. II. Creation and
                  • Cuzzi J.N.
                    ,
                  • Davis S.S.
                    ,
                  • Dobrovolskis A.R.
                  • 1974a, On the origin of close binaries
                    • Drobyshevski E.M.
                      • Astron.Astrophys. 36 409
                  • 1974b, Was Jupiter the protosun's core?
                    • Drobyshevski E.M.
                      • Nature 250 35
                  • 1975, On the chemical composition of the Moon, Jupiter, meteorites
                    • Drobyshevski E.M.
                    • and Am stars
                        • Earth Planet.Sci.Lett. 25 368
                    • 1976, How do binary stars appear? Zemlya i Vselennaya (The Earth
                      • Drobyshevski E.M.
                      • 1977, Long-period comets and transneptunian planets. Astron. Tsirk
                        • Drobyshevski E.M.
                        • 1978, The origin of the Solar system: Implications for transneptunian
                          • Drobyshevski E.M.
                          • planets and the nature of the long-period comets
                              • Moon Planets 18 145
                          • 1980a, Electrolysis in space and fate of Phaethon. Moon Planets 23
                            • Drobyshevski E.M.
                            • 1980b, The eruptive evolution of the Galilean satellites: Implication
                              • Drobyshevski E.M.