Regularity properties and pathologies of position space renormalization group transformations: Scope and limitations of Gibbsian theory

Sokal, Alan D.; van Enter, A.C.D.; Fernandez, R.

doi:10.1007/BF01048183

Regularity properties and pathologies of position space renormalization group transformations: Scope and limitations of Gibbsian theory

1994

273 pages

Published in:

J.Statist.Phys. 72 (1994) 879-1167

e-Print:

hep-lat/9210032 [hep-lat]

DOI:

10.1007/BF01048183

Report number:

NYU-TH-92-10-02

View in:

pdf

reference search55 citations

Citations per year

Abstract:

We reconsider the conceptual foundations of the renormalization-group (RG) formalism, and prove some rigorous theorems on the regularity properties and possible pathologies of the RG map. Regarding regularity, we show that the RG map, defined on a suitable space of interactions (= formal Hamiltonians), is always single-valued and Lipschitz continuous on its domain of definition. This rules out a recently proposed scenario for the RG description of first-order phase transitions. On the pathological side, we make rigorous some arguments of Griffiths, Pearce and Israel, and prove in several cases that the renormalized measure is not a Gibbs measure for any reasonable interaction. This means that the RG map is ill-defined, and that the conventional RG description of first-order phase transitions is not universally valid. For decimation or Kadanoff transformations applied to the Ising model in dimension

d \ge 3

, these pathologies occur in a full neighborhood

\{ \beta > \beta_0 ,\, |h| < \epsilon(\beta) \}

of the low-temperature part of the first-order phase-transition surface. For block-averaging transformations applied to the Ising model in dimension

d \ge 2

, the pathologies occur at low temperatures for arbitrary magnetic-field strength. Pathologies may also occur in the critical region for Ising models in dimension

d \ge 4

. We discuss in detail the distinction between Gibbsian and non-Gibbsian measures, and give a rather complete catalogue of the known examples. Finally, we discuss the heuristic and numerical evidence on RG pathologies in the light of our rigorous theorems.

Note:

273 pages including 14 figures, Postscript, See also ftp.scri.fsu.edu:hep-lat/papers/9210/9210032.ps.Z

References(372)

Figures(0)

[1]

Translation invariance and instability of phase coexistence in the two dimensional Ising system 94, 1980

M. Aizenman

- Commun.Math.Phys. 73 83

[2]

Geometric Analysis of phi**4 Fields and Ising Models (Parts 1 & 2)

Michael Aizenman
(
- Princeton U.
)

- Commun.Math.Phys. 86 (1982) 1
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF01205659

[3]

The Intersection of Brownian Paths as a Case Study of a Renormalization Group Method for Quantum Field Theory

Michael Aizenman
(
- Rutgers U., Piscataway
)

- Commun.Math.Phys. 97 (1985) 91
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF01206180

[4]

ON A SHARP TRANSITION FROM AREA LAW TO PERIMETER LAW IN A SYSTEM OF RANDOM SURFACES

M. Aizenman
(
- Rutgers U., Piscataway
)
,
J.T. Chayes
(
- Princeton U.
)
,
L. Chayes
(
- Princeton U.
)
,
L. Russo
(
- Princeton U.
)
,
J. Frohlich
(
- Zurich, ETH
)

- Commun.Math.Phys. 92 (1983) 19-69,
- Commun. Math. Phys. 92 ( 1983) 19-69
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF01206313

[5]

Discontinuity of the magnetization in one-dimensional 1=jx yj2 Ising and Potts models 40, 1988

M. Aizenman
,
J.T. Chayes
,
L. Chayes
,
C.M. Newman

- J.Statist.Phys. 50 1

[6]

On the critical behavior of the magnetization in high-dimensional Ising models 454, 1986

M. Aizenman
,
R. Fernandez

- J.Statist.Phys. 44 393

[7]

On the renormalized coupling constant and the susceptibility in '4 4 eld theory and the Ising model in four dimensions. Nuclear Physics, B225 FS9]:261{288, 1983

M. Aizenman
,
R. Graham

[8]

The third law of thermodynamics and the degeneracy of the ground state for lattice systems 297, 1981

M. Aizenman
,
E. Lieb

- J.Statist.Phys. 24 279

[9]

A variational method for estimating the parameters of MRF from complete or incomplete data. Brown University preprint, 1990

M.P. Almeidaand B. Gidas

[10]

ON DANGEROUS IRRELEVANT OPERATORS

Daniel J. Amit
(
- Hebrew U.
)
,
Luca Peliti
(
- Rome U.
)

- Annals Phys. 140 (1982) 207
•
DOI:
- 10.1016/0003-4916(82)90159-2

[11]

Some numerical results on the Kondo problem and the inverse-square one-dimensional Ising model 620, 1971

P.W. Anderson
,
G. Yuval

- J.Phys.C 4 607

[12]

Exact results in the Kondo problem. II. Scaling theory, qualitatively correct solution, and some new results on one-dimensional classical statistical models 4473, 1970

P.W. Anderson
,
G. Yuval
,
D.R. Hamann

- Phys.Rev.B 1 4464

[13]

C. Arag~ao Caracciolo, and J. Frohlich. Polymers and g'4 theory in four dimensions. Nucl. Phys., B215 FS7]:209{248, 1983

S. de Carvalho

[14]

Rigorous analysis of renormalization group pathologies in the 4-state clock model. Preprint, 1992

M. Asorey
,
J.G. Esteve
,
R. Fernandez
,
J. Salas

[15]

Gibbs description of random elds whose conditional probabilities may vanish 334, 1975

M.B. Averintsev

- Probl.Info.Transm. 11 326

[16]

Some Limit Theorems in Statistics Philadelphia, 1971

R.R. Bahadur

[17]

Renormalization Group Structure for Translationally Invariant Ferromagnets

G.A. Baker
(
- Los Alamos
)
,
S. Krinsky
(
- Brookhaven
)

- J.Math.Phys. 18 (1977) 590-607
•
DOI:
- 10.1063/1.523341

[18]

J. Frohlich, editor. Ultraviolet stability in eld theory. The 4 3 model. In Scaling and Self-Similarity in Physics. Birkhauser, Boston{Basel{Stuttgart, 1983

T. Balaban

[19]

Large Field Renormalization. 2: Localization, Exponentiation, and Bounds for the R Operation

T. Balaban
(
- Boston U.
)

- Commun.Math.Phys. 122 (1989) 355-392
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF01238433

[20]

From Microphysics to Macrophysics: Methods and Applications of Statistical Physics Verlag, Berlin{New York, 1991

R. Balian

[21]

Complete phase diagrams with respect to external elds at low temperatures for models with nearest-neighbor interaction in the case of a nite or countable number of ground states 182, 1984

A.G. Basuev

- Theor.Math.Phys. 58 171

[22]

Hamiltonian of the phase separation border and phase transitions of the rst kind. I 734, 1985

A.G. Basuev

- Theor.Math.Phys. 64 716

[23]

Hamiltonian of the phase separation border and phase transitions of the rst kind. II. The simplest disordered phases 871, 1987

A.G. Basuev

- Theor.Math.Phys. 72 861

[24]

The FKG inequality for the Yukawa2 quantum eld theory 192, 1980

G.A. Battle
,
L. Rosen

- J.Statist.Phys. 22 123

[25]

Probability Theory and Elements of Measure Theory. Holt, Rinehart and Winston, New York, 1972

H. Bauer

1-25 of 372
1
2
3
4
5
•••
15
25 / page