Superiority of the h-index over the impact factor for physics
Aug, 2006Citations per year
0 Citations
Abstract:
Focusing specifically on physics periodicals, I show that the journal Impact Factor is not correlated with Hirsch's -index. This implies that the Impact Factor is not a good measure of research quality or influence because the -index is a reflection of peer review, and thus a strong indicator of research quality. The impact gap between multidisciplinary journals and physics-only journals is significantly reduced when is used instead of the Impact Factor. Additionally, the impact of journals specializing in review articles is inherently deflated using because of the limited number of annual publications in such periodicals. Finally, a reordering of the top ranking journals occurs with when only the physics articles of multidisciplinary journals are considered, falling more in line with the average physicist's interpretation of a journal's prestige.Note:
- Submitted to Am.J.Phys.
References(8)
Figures(0)
- [6]
- [9]
- [10]
- [12]
- [13]
- [13]
- [14]
- [16]