Exploring the trade-off between computational power and energy efficiency: An analysis of the evolution of quantum computing and its relation to classical computing

Desdentado, Elena; Calero, Coral; Moraga, Ma Ángeles; Serrano, Manuel; García, Félix

doi:10.1016/j.jss.2024.112165

Exploring the trade-off between computational power and energy efficiency: An analysis of the evolution of quantum computing and its relation to classical computing

Elena Desdentado
(
- Castilla-La Mancha U.
)
,
Coral Calero
(
- Castilla-La Mancha U. and
- VTT Electronics, Espoo
)
,
Ma Ángeles Moraga
(
- Castilla-La Mancha U. and
- VTT Electronics, Espoo
)
,
Manuel Serrano
(
- Castilla-La Mancha U. and
- VTT Electronics, Espoo
)
,
Félix García
(
- Castilla-La Mancha U. and
- VTT Electronics, Espoo
)

Jul 29, 2024

14 pages

Published in:

The Journal of Systems & Software 217 (2024) 112165

Published: Jul 29, 2024

DOI:

10.1016/j.jss.2024.112165 (publication)

reference search1 citation

Citations per year

Abstract: (Elsevier Inc.)

Quantum computing is considered a revolutionary technology due to its ability to solve computational problems that are beyond the capabilities of classical computers. However, quantum computing requires great amounts of energy to run. Therefore, a factor in deciding whether to use quantum computing should be not only the complexity of the problem to be solved, but also the energy required to solve it. This paper presents an empirical study developed with the aim of comparing classical and quantum computing in terms of energy efficiency to determine whether the increased power of quantum computers is offset by their higher energy consumption. To achieve this, a variety of problems with different levels of complexity were tested on both types of computers. Specifically, we used the IBM Quantum computers with a maximum of 5 qubits and an Intel i7, as a classical computer. In addition to this we have also analysed the evolution of the quantum computers, performing measurements on three time periods. Our empirical study showed that there is a variability of results obtained in the three time periods and that quantum computing is not recommended for low-complexity problems, given its high energy consumption, particularly when compared to traditional computing. •Quantum problems tested take 679 to 903 times longer than classical computing.•Quantum used about 155,308 times more energy than classical for the easiest problem.•High energy use and variable times favour classical computers for simple problems.