Complementarity Is Not Enough

The near-horizon field B of an old black hole is maximally entangled with the early Hawking radiation R, by unitarity of the S-matrix. But B must be maximally entangled with the black hole interior A, by the equivalence principle. Causal patch complementarity fails to reconcile these conflicting requirements. The system B can be probed by a freely falling observer while there is still time to turn around and remain outside the black hole. Therefore, the entangled state of the BR system is dictated by unitarity even in the infalling patch. If, by monogamy of entanglement, B is not entangled with A, the horizon is replaced by a singularity or “firewall.” To illustrate the radical nature of the ideas that are needed, I briefly discuss two approaches for avoiding a firewall: the identification of A with a subsystem of R; and a combination of patch complementarity with the Horowitz-Maldacena final-state proposal.

Note:

14 pages, 1 figure. v2: Completely rewritten

04.70.Dy
radiation: Hawking
equivalence principle: violation
black hole
unitarity
causality
diamond
horizon
S-matrix
entanglement: quantum

References(42)

Figures(2)

[1]

Black Holes: Complementarity or Firewalls?

Ahmed Almheiri
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)
,
Donald Marolf
(
- UC, Santa Barbara and
- Santa Barbara, KITP
)
,
Joseph Polchinski
(
- Santa Barbara, KITP
)
,
James Sully
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)

- JHEP 02 (2013) 062
•
e-Print:
- 1207.3123
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/JHEP02(2013)062

[2]

The Stretched horizon and black hole complementarity

- Phys.Rev.D 48 (1993) 3743-3761,
- Phys. Rev. D48 (1993) 3743-3761 and Stanford Univ. - SU-ITP-93-15 (93/06,rec.Jul.) 46 p
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/9306069
•
DOI:
- 10.1103/PhysRevD.48.3743

[3]

Microscopic origin of the Bekenstein-Hawking entropy

Andrew Strominger
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)
,
Cumrun Vafa
(
- Harvard U.
)

- Phys.Lett.B 379 (1996) 99-104
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/9601029
•
DOI:
- 10.1016/0370-2693(96)00345-0

[4]

The Large N limit of superconformal field theories and supergravity

Juan Martin Maldacena
(
- Harvard U.
)

- Int.J.Theor.Phys. 38 (1999) 1113-1133 (reprint),
- Adv.Theor.Math.Phys. 2 (1998) 231-252
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/9711200
•
DOI:
- 10.4310/ATMP.1998.v2.n2.a1

[5]

Black holes and the second law

J.D. Bekenstein
(
- Princeton U.
)

- Lett.Nuovo Cim. 4 (1972) 737-740
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF02757029

[6]

Particle Creation by Black Holes

S.W. Hawking
(
- Cambridge U., DAMTP and
- Caltech
)

- Commun.Math.Phys. 43 (1975) 199-220,
- Commun.Math.Phys. 46 (1976) 206 (erratum),
•
DOI:
- 10.1007/BF02345020

[7]

Average entropy of a subsystem

Don N. Page
(
- Alberta U.
)

- Phys.Rev.Lett. 71 (1993) 1291-1294
•
e-Print:
- gr-qc/9305007
•
DOI:
- 10.1103/PhysRevLett.71.1291

[8]

Notes on black hole evaporation

W.G. Unruh
(
- McMaster U.
)

- Phys.Rev.D 14 (1976) 870
•
DOI:
- 10.1103/PhysRevD.14.870

[9]

Complementarity Is Not Enough

Raphael Bousso
(
- UC, Berkeley and
- LBL, Berkeley
)

- Phys.Rev.D 87 (2013) 12, 124023
•
e-Print:
- 1207.5192
•
DOI:
- 10.1103/PhysRevD.87.124023

[10]

Positive vacuum energy and the N bound

Raphael Bousso
(
- UC, Santa Barbara
)

- JHEP 11 (2000) 038
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/0010252
•
DOI:
- 10.1088/1126-6708/2000/11/038

[11]

A Covariant entropy conjecture

Raphael Bousso
(
- Stanford U., Phys. Dept.
)

- JHEP 07 (1999) 004
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/9905177
•
DOI:
- 10.1088/1126-6708/1999/07/004

[12]

M theory observables for cosmological space-times

Tom Banks
(
- UC, Santa Cruz
)
,
W. Fischler
(
- Texas U.
)

e-Print:
- hep-th/0102077

[13]

An Holographic cosmology

T. Banks
(
- UC, Santa Cruz
)
,
W. Fischler
(
- Texas U.
)

e-Print:
- hep-th/0111142

[14]

Holographic cosmology

T. Banks
(
- Rutgers U., Piscataway and
- UC, Santa Cruz
)
,
W. Fischler
(
- Texas U.
)

e-Print:
- hep-th/0405200

[15]

TASI Lectures on Holographic Space-Time, SUSY and Gravitational Effective Field Theory

Tom Banks
(
- Rutgers U., Piscataway and
- UC, Santa Cruz
)

e-Print:
- 1007.4001

[16]

Holographic Space-Time: The Takeaway

Tom Banks
(
- Rutgers U., Piscataway and
- UC, Santa Cruz
)

e-Print:
- 1109.2435

[17]

Do black holes destroy information?

John Preskill
(
- Caltech
)

- ,
- In *Houston 1992, Proceedings, Black holes, membranes, wormholes and superstrings* 22-39, and Caltech Pasadena - CALT-68-1819 (92,rec.Oct.) 17 p
•
e-Print:
- hep-th/9209058

[18]